up SearchFeedback[help] CPMCnet

New and Future Treatments for Chronic Hepatitis C

This article first appeared in the Spring/Summer 2001 edition of the American Liver Foundation, Greater New York Chapter's, View Points newsletter.

Howard J. Worman, M. D.
Division of Digestive and Liver Diseases
Departments of Medicine and of Anatomy and Cell Biology
College of Physicians and Surgeons
Columbia University
New York, NY 10032

Treatment of chronic hepatitis C is presently based on the use of interferon-alpha. Interferon-alpha is a protein that is given by injection, usually three times a week. The addition of ribivirin, a non-specific, orally administered anti-viral agent, improves the efficacy of interferon-alpha. Although interferon-alpha with or without ribivirin works for some patients with hepatitis C, most do not achieve a "sustained response" of undetectable virus in blood 6 months after stopping therapy. Interferon-alpha is also associated with myriad adverse events and is relatively expensive. Ribavirin may also cause side effects. Better drugs are unequivocally needed for the treatment of chronic hepatitis C. What will they likely be?

Longer Acting Interferon-alpha

The next drug available for the treatment of chronic hepatitis C will be peginterferon-alpha (sometimes called "pegylated interferon"). The active agent in peginterferon-alpha is the same old interferon-alpha. However, the protein is attached to polyethylene glycol (antifreeze), an inert compound that slows the elimination from the body. More constant blood levels of interferon-alpha are achieved with less frequent injections, usually once a week. This results in enhanced compliance and clinically superior anti-viral activity.

Published studies have shown that peginterferon-alpha alone results in "sustained response" rates of 30% to almost 40%. The side effect profile is similar to unmodified interferon-alpha. Preliminary data show that addition of oral ribavirin to pegylated interferon-alpha results in "sustained response" rates of approximately 50%. Hence, pegylation enhances the efficacy of interferon-alpha for the treatment of chronic hepatitis C.

The United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has recently approved peginterferon-alpha-2b (Peg-Intron, Schering-Plough) for the treatment of chronic hepatitis C. Peginterferon-alpha-2a (Pegasys, Hoffmann La Roche) will likely be approved in the near future. Within a year, the FDA will likely approve the combination of peginterferon-alphas with ribavirin. Clinical trials of peginterferon-alpha with a compound called VX-497 (Vertex Pharmaceuticals) are also in progress. VX-497 has some features similar to ribavirin and inhibits a cellular enzyme know as inosine monophosphate dehydrogenase that may responsible for some of its effects.

An even longer acting form on interferon-alpha is currently in early stage clinical testing. This is a fusion protein between albumin and interferon alpha (Albuferon, Human Genome Sciences). Data on its clinical efficacy are not yet available. It is also probable that other long acting preparations of interferon-alpha will be developed in the next few years.

Drugs that Affect the Immune Response Against the Virus

Several drugs known as "immune modifiers" or "immunomodulators" that alter the immune response are being tested in clinical trials for chronic hepatitis C. Some are being studied along with interferon-alpha. There drugs alter the inflammatory response against liver cells infected with the virus; however, their mechanisms of action are poorly understood. Compounds of this type currently being tested in humans include thymosin-alpha-1 (Zadaxin, SciClone Pharmaceuticals) and histamine dihydrocholoride (Ceplene, Maxim Pharmaceuticals).

Therapeutic vaccines are also being developed to enhance the immune response against the hepatitis C virus. In contrast to a preventive vaccine, which is likely to be a very long way off for hepatitis C, a therapeutic vaccine is administered to already-infected individuals to stimulate the immune system to fight the infection. Several therapeutic vaccines are in preclinical development for hepatitis C. The most promising of these are DNA vaccines involving injection of DNA copies of the hepatitis C virus's RNA genome, which are taken up by certain immune system cells. These cells then express viral proteins, stimulating an immune response against the virus. These theoretically appealing therapeutic vaccine for hepatitis C remain to be shown effective in human subjects

Specific Agents Against Hepatitis C Virus Proteins

A new generation of drugs to treat hepatitis C will be those designed specifically to inhibit functions of the hepatitis C virus. One target for such drugs is the hepatitis C virus RNA genome. Ribozymes are catalytic RNA molecules, some of which can cut other RNA molecules. A ribozyme (Hepatazyme, Ribozyme Pharmaceuticals) has been designed to cleave the hepatitis C virus RNA genome in a region that the virus needs to survive. Its efficacy in cutting hepatitis C virus RNA has been established in the test tube and the drug is now in early clinical trials. ISIS-14803 (Isis Pharmaceuticals) is a antisense inhibitor complementary to a conserved sequence of the hepatitis C virus RNA. This molecule binds to the viral RNA and inhibits the expression of proteins required for replication. ISIS-14803 is currently in early stage clinical trials. A small molecule known as VP-50406 (ViroPharma) has also been demonstrated to inhibit hepatitis C virus RNA in the laboratory and is in early stage clinical development. Inhibitors of a unique structure of the hepatitis C virus RNA necessary for protein synthesis, known as the internal ribosome entry site or IRES, are also under study in the laboratory.

Three favorite targets of the hepatitis C virus for pharmaceutical chemists are its N3S RNA polymerase, NS3 RNA helicase and NS5B RNA polymerase. Compounds directed against these targets are in various stages of preclinical development. The targets are all enzymes (proteins that catalyze chemical reactions) essential for hepatitis C virus replication. They are expressed in cells infected with the virus but not in mature viral particles themselves. Armed with knowledge of the three-dimensional structures of these enzymes deduced using X-ray crystallography, scientists can identify molecules that inhibit their activities.

NS3 has two parts with distinct enzymatic activities. One part is a protease that cuts a larger precursor protein encoded by the hepatitis C virus RNA into smaller functional proteins. Inhibition of NS3 would result in a failure of the virus to make the smaller proteins necessary for its replication. The other part of NS3 is a RNA helicase that unwinds the hepatitis C viral RNA. RNA unwinding is necessary for its efficient replication and translation into protein. Specific inhibitors of NS3's enzymatic activities would theoretically not influence critical host cell functions, limiting the side effect profiles. NS5B of the hepatitis C virus is an essential RNA-dependent RNA polymerase that copies the virus's RNA genome. Animal cells do not copy RNA; they make RNA copies from DNA. Therefore, specific inhibitors of the NS5B should not affect host cell processes.

Of course, one cannot accurately predict the adverse event profile of a given drug until it is tested in human. Drugs designed as best as possible against specific viral targets may still prove to have side effects. However, well-designed drugs directed against the hepatitis C virus RNA, NS3 protease, NS3 RNA helicase and NS5AB RNA polymerase are very likely to be more effective and better tolerated than currently available treatments for hepatitis C. The timeline from the laboratory to the clinic is likely to be several years.

Drugs that Affect the Liver's Response to Injury

Chronic hepatitis (inflammation of the liver) can lead to fibrosis (scarring) and cirrhosis (fibrosis plus abnormal regeneration of liver cells). Virtually all of the serious complications of chronic hepatitis C result from cirrhosis. For this reason, several groups are developing drugs to prevent fibrosis and cirrhosis. Recent data suggest that fibrosis, and perhaps even early cirrhosis, may be reversible to some extent.

Very little is known about why the liver becomes fibrotic in response to chronic inflammation. Furthermore, it is not known why some individuals infected with the hepatitis C virus develop significant fibrosis or cirrhosis while others never do. Some drugs that may prevent liver fibrosis and cirrhosis are in early clinical trials. IP-501 (Interneuron Pharmaceuticals) is an orally administered anti-fibrotic compound being tested for the treatment of including alcoholic and hepatitis C-induced cirrhosis. Animal models suggest that IP-501 is effective in preventing the development of alcohol-induced cirrhosis, however the exact mechanism by which this compound works is not fully understood. Clinical trials of IP-501 in alcohol-induced liver disease and chronic hepatitis C are underway. Preliminary studies in humans have also shown that interleukin-10 (Schering-Plough) may prevent liver fibrosis in chronic hepatitis C. Clinical trials of interleukin-10 need to be carried out on a larger scale to demonstrate safety and efficacy. Increasing scientific effort is being devoted to the study of liver fibrosis in response to injury and exciting new drugs to prevent it will hopefully be available someday.

Re-grow a Damaged Liver?

When a liver is damaged beyond repair, the only hope today is orthotopic liver transplantation. However, considerable research effort is being devoted to the study of stem cells. Stem cells are undifferentiated cells, such as those in the early embryo that can be directed to form many different tissues of the body. In the past few of years, investigators have shown that liver stem cells reside in the bone marrow. Theoretically, these bone marrow stem cells can be isolated and grown into hepatocytes and bile duct cells in the laboratory. Some animal studies have also shown that expression of the enzyme telomerase in liver cells enhance their ability to regenerate. Although considerable challenges remain to be overcome, this early stage research provides promise that liver transplantation may someday be a thing of the past.

Pharacogenomics

Some drugs work in some patients but not in others. Similarly, some drugs have side effects in some patients while others tolerate them well. For example, less than half of patients with chronic hepatitis C have a "sustained response" to treatment with interferon-alpha and many experience intolerable side effects. Most of this is a result of different individuals' different genetic make-ups.

Pharmacogenomics is the science of understanding the correlation between an individual patient's genetic make-up and response to a drug. The discipline is evolving rapidly as a result of the extensive work recently completed on sequencing the entire human genome. Phamacogenomics aims to identify genetic markers that predict response to a drug. The genetic markers commonly assessed are known a single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and haplotypes. SNPs are changes at a single base of DNA between individuals. Haplotypes are linear arrays of slightly different forms of particular genes on a chromosome. By studying populations of patients and their responses to a drug, inheritance of a collection of SNPs or different haplotypes can be correlated with successful treatment, unsuccessful treatment or development of side effects. This knowledge can them be used to "customize" drug therapy for a particular patient based on first examining their DNA. Click here to return to Diseases of the Liver home page.

Copyright, 2001, Howard J. Worman, M. D. All rights reserved. Printing or other reproduction is prohibited without the written authorization of Howard J. Worman.
Current Papers in Liver Disease/Howard J. Worman, M. D./hjw14@columbia.edu